Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles Cost – Is a Metal Roof Worth It?

When comparing the cost of metal roofing vs. shingles, there are a few factors to consider. Here is an in-depth look at the cost comparison between the two roofing materials:

1. 1. Initial Cost: The initial cost of metal roofing is generally higher than that of shingles. Our research shows the average cost to install a new metal roof is between $11.50 and $20.50 per square foot, depending on the type of metal and project specifics, while asphalt shingles typically cost between $4.50 and $9.50 per square foot.

New Shingle Roof $7,500 Average price	New Metal Roof $14,500 Average price	New Flat Roof $8,225 Average price
See costs in your area Enter Your Zip Code

1. Long-term Cost: Although metal roofing is more expensive initially, it can be more cost-effective over the long-term. Metal roofing is more durable than shingles and can last 30 to 60 years, while shingles typically last 15 to 30 years. This means that you may need to replace shingles multiple times over the lifespan of a metal roof, increasing the long-term cost of shingles.
2. Energy Efficiency: Metal roofing is generally far more energy-efficient than shingles. Metal reflects solar radiant heat, which can reduce the amount of heat absorbed into your home and lower your energy bills. Look for CRRC colors with a Kynar 500 paint finish to maximize energy savings with a metal roof. Additionally, some metal roofing systems can be installed with insulation to further increase  your home’s energy efficiency.
3. Maintenance: Metal roofing is very low-maintenance and requires little upkeep over its lifespan. Shingles, on the other hand, can be prone to damage from storm winds, wind driven rain, ice dams, moss and mildew growth, and other weather conditions, and may require more frequent maintenance and repair.
4. Resale Value: In the short run, an asphalt roof can offer better cost-to-value return than metal. In the long run, though, a metal roof will maintain its value for decades, whereas an asphalt roof will not. So, 10-15 years down the road, an asphalt roof may offer very little in terms of retained value and may be viewed more as a liability by potential buyers.

While the initial cost of metal roofing is higher than that of shingles, it can be more cost-effective over the long-term due to its durability, longevity, and energy efficiency. Additionally, metal roofing can add lasting value to your home and increase its resale value, maintaining it for decades to come.

Availability of Styles and Colors

When it comes to style and color options, both metal roofing and shingles offer a variety of choices. However, metal roofing also offers additional options, including metal shingles, shakes, and tiles, as well as stone-coated steel options. Here’s an in-depth look at the availability of styles and colors for metal roofing and shingles:

1. 1. Metal Roofing Styles and Colors: Metal roofing is available in a wide range of styles, including standing seam, batter seam, corrugated, and ribbed metal panels. Standing seam metal roofing is, by far, the most popular choice, known for its clean, modern look and durability. Corrugated and ribbed metal roofing are typically less expensive than standing seam, but can still offer a unique and stylish look (however they are mostly, but not always, used in commercial and industrial applications). In addition, metal roofing is available in metal shingles, shakes, and tiles, which offer a more traditional or classic appearance. Stone-coated steel roofing options are also available, which offer the look of traditional shingles or tiles with the durability of metal. Metal roofing is available in a wide range of colors, including standard colors like white, gray, and black, green, grey, metallic, red, blue, as well as custom colors to match your home’s exterior.

1. Shingle Styles and Colors: Shingles are available in a variety of styles, including architectural, three-tab, and designer shingles. Architectural shingles are the most popular choice, known for their dimensional look and durability. Three-tab shingles are a more affordable option, but have a flat, less textured appearance. Designer shingles offer a unique and customized look, with options like slate or cedar shake shingles. Shingles are also available in a wide range of colors, including standard colors like gray, black, and brown, as well as variegated colors to match your home’s exterior.

When comparing the availability of styles and colors for metal roofing vs. shingles, it’s important to consider the style and design of your home, as well as your personal preferences. Metal roofing offers a modern and sleek look with a variety of styles, including standing seam, metal shingles, shakes, and tiles, as well as stone-coated steel options that offer the look of traditional shingles or tiles. Both metal roofing and shingles offer a wide range of color options to choose from, making it easy to find a color that complements your home’s exterior.

Overall, the availability of styles and colors for metal roofing and shingles is comparable, with metal roofing offering additional options like metal shingles, shakes, and tiles, as well as stone-coated steel options. It’s important to work with a professional roofing contractor to explore your options and find the best choice for your home and budget.

Real Life Hurricane Performance Comparison

1. Metal Roof Performance: Metal roofs are known for their durability and resistance to high winds, making them a popular choice in hurricane-prone areas. In fact, metal roofs have been shown to perform well in hurricane conditions, with some metal roofs able to withstand winds of up to 120-140 mph. Metal roofs are also less likely to suffer from wind-driven rain or hail damage (especially stone-coated steel roofs – the only material warrantied to withstand hail impact), making them a reliable choice in areas prone to severe weather.
2. Asphalt Roof Performance: Asphalt roofs are a popular roofing material due to their affordability and ease of installation. However, they are less durable and more prone to damage from high winds and severe weather. In hurricane conditions, asphalt roofs are more likely to suffer from wind damage, with shingles being torn off or the entire roof being lifted off the home. Asphalt roofs are also more likely to suffer from water damage due to wind-driven rain.

In real-life hurricane events, metal roofs have demonstrated their durability and resistance to hurricane damage. For example, after Hurricane Harvey in 2017, homeowners with metal roofs reported little to no damage to their roofs, while those with asphalt roofs suffered significant damage. In addition, after Hurricane Michael in 2018, metal roofs were found to have fared much better than asphalt roofs, with many metal roofs still intact and undamaged.

Overall, metal roofs have shown to be a more reliable and durable option in hurricane-prone areas, with their ability to withstand high winds and resist water damage. While asphalt roofs are more affordable, they are also more susceptible to hurricane damage, making them a riskier choice in areas prone to severe weather. When considering roofing options for your home in a hurricane-prone area, it’s important to consider the potential for hurricane damage and choose a roof that can withstand these conditions.

Warranty Comparison

When it comes to warranties, metal roofing generally has a longer lifespan and a longer warranty period compared to shingles. Here’s an in-depth look at the warranties for metal roofing and shingles:

1. Metal Roofing Warranties: Most metal roofing manufacturers offer warranties ranging from 20 to 50 years, depending on the type of metal and the manufacturer. Some manufacturers even offer lifetime warranties, which can provide peace of mind for homeowners. These warranties typically cover defects in the metal roofing material, including chipping, peeling, cracking, and fading.
2. Shingle Warranties: Shingle warranties typically range from 15 to 30 years, depending on the quality of the shingles and the manufacturer. Some manufacturers offer longer warranties, up to 50 years, for high-end shingles. Shingle warranties typically cover defects in the shingle material, including cracking, curling, and discoloration.

It’s important to note that both metal roofing and shingle warranties are typically prorated, meaning that the warranty coverage decreases over time. Additionally, warranties may only cover the cost of the materials and not the cost of labor for installation or repairs.

When considering warranties for metal roofing vs. shingles, it’s important to also consider the durability and longevity of each material. Metal roofing is generally more durable and long-lasting than shingles, which can offset the higher initial cost of metal roofing. Additionally, metal roofing is more resistant to damage from weather and pests, which can help reduce repair costs over time.

Overall, both metal roofing and shingles come with warranties, but metal roofing warranties are typically longer and cover more potential issues. However, it’s important to carefully review the terms and conditions of any warranty and consult with a professional roofing contractor to determine the best option for your home and budget.